After
a night of tossing and turning, anticipation shook me out of sleep. It was only
five in the morning in France, but I wanted to feel a part of the election
excitement back home—wanted to witness the results of this historical election
in real time. I had even baked a celebration cake the night before to share
with my French students and colleagues.
I
clicked open a live-stream. At first, I thought my early-morning brain fog must
have been playing tricks on me. America was spattered red—in all the right
places. My heart dropped when I saw Ohio. Then once again when I laid eyes on
Florida. In desperation, I looked to the commentators for comfort, but it
seemed that even they were in denial—trying to talk themselves out of what was
clearly about to happen. Up until yesterday evening, I had spent the entire
year reassuring my French friends that Donald Trump would never win. It was as
if I had woken up in an alternate universe.
I hid
under the covers as long as I could. Then, seeing I had just ten minutes to get
to school, I threw on some clothes, tried my best to wash the look of shock off
my face, and covered my tired eyes with globs of makeup and crooked eyeliner.
When
I opened the door to the teacher’s room, everyone stopped in their tracks. They
stared. They were waiting for me to say something, to speak for my country. I
just stood there, holding out my cake. In desperation, I tried to pull one of
my colleagues into a hug, but unfortunately it’s not a gesture that the French
understand or appreciate. My colleague’s body stayed limp in my arms, waiting
for the “hug” to end. Then, the jokes started to fire: “The first orange president!”. But I wasn’t
laughing. This past year had been nothing but Donald Trump jokes, nothing but
the constant mocking and questioning of Americans, nothing but trying our best
to laugh off the fear. It wasn’t funny anymore, because now it was real.
Just
when I thought I couldn’t feel any worse, the bell rang. I made my way to my
classroom, wading through the stares, whispers, and giggles of students. An
understanding colleague, noticing my discomfort, put a hand on my shoulder and
said, “Don’t worry, they won’t be laughing when Marine Le Pen wins the election
in a few months.”
It is
now a few months later, and I replay those words over and over in my head. I
feel like I am reliving the same strange story. Recently, France voted to send
Marine Le Pen through to the final round of the presidential election. Like
Trump’s slogan “Make America Great Again,” Marine Le Pen rose to the top with
the motto “The French Come First.” Like Trump, Marine claims to be a protector
of the people, as she snaps selfies with factory workers whose jobs will soon
be outsourced to Poland. Like Trump, Marine harnesses the rise of unemployment
and a fear of terrorism to turn the population against immigrants. Perhaps most
importantly, a vote for Marine means pulling the thread that will unravel the
European Union.
After
graduating from Smith College, I came to France to teach English. It was a
passion for my job and the French way of life that made me stay for what has
now become five years. While I could rest assured that the majority of French
people, whether on the left or the right, could agree on certain basic human
rights—health care, free education, a woman’s right to choose, strict gun
control—in America these were the issues that divided our nation. What’s more,
French voter turnout for presidential elections has always remained at or above
80 percent, whereas our own turnout has recently hovered around 60 percent. For
me, France is country that is much more united than the United States of
America, and united on the issues that, frankly, just shouldn’t be issues at
all. After last week’s election results, I trusted that France would turn
fiercely against Le Pen’s candidacy.
To my
surprise, my “déjà vu” is worsening as I hear from more and more people that
they have decided that they will not vote next Sunday. Some, who were inspired
by the Bernie Sanders-like movement led by far left candidate, Jean-Luc
Mélenchon, are disappointed with the results. Labeled the “French Chavez” by
the French newspaper “Le Figaro,” they feel the media favored centrist Emmanuel
Macron, and that democracy is not functioning as it should. Others, who favored
Republican candidate François Fillon, whose presidential chances were ruined by
scandal, cannot imagine voting for Macron.
Naturally,
I chided friends who announced to me that they wouldn’t vote. I couldn’t
understand how after the lessons of Brexit and Trump, France could leave this
election up to chance. Even my own place is threatened by Le Pen, who vows to
freeze long-term visas and to increase taxes for companies who hire foreign
workers. My friends, who have decided not to vote, all respond with different
combinations of the same words: “Don’t worry, Kayla. You won’t have to leave.
Marine won’t win, anyway. And look at Trump, has he been able to do anything?
In any case, you’re American. Nothing will happen to you.”
Let’s
take this apart, piece-by-piece. First of all, the assumption that Marine
“won’t win” is one that I am all too familiar with. Yes, the polls say Macron
will win. Yes, Marine Le Pen "lost" the presidential debates. We all
felt the same about Trump, and Brexit.
But let's not be too sure that the election is already in the bag.
Luckily, I'm not the only skeptic. One French friend cited the Holocaust as the
ultimate lesson: “How can people vote for Le Pen, or abstain from voting, when
our country lived through World War II? How can they be so irresponsible?”.
While Marine has tried to reinvent the image of her party, the Front National
is known for anti-Semitic statements and also for denying the holocaust. Isn’t
that alone, reason enough to vote against her next Sunday?
Now,
let us consider the problematic preference of Americans over “other”
foreigners. What makes my nationality more “preferable” than another? What
makes me “safer” than a Syrian? By acknowledging that I am “safer,” that I am
not the one “they will be looking for,” you are admitting that in Le Pen’s
France, there will be targets. Shouldn't we be doing everything we can to
shield these people from harm? By not voting, you reveal your privilege. You
are ignoring a passive racism that is running through France’s veins and racing
for France’s heart. Your own life may not change if Marine comes to power, and
maybe not even your American friend’s life, but the unfortunate will suffer.
Xenophobia has been trying to rear its ugly head in France for decades. Now is
the most important time to remain vigilant.
Finally:
the idea that “Trump hasn’t been able to do anything.” The impending
destruction of the planet aside, let’s think about the importance of words and
images. Even if a head of a country is tied back by checks and balances, words
and images are very powerful. After Brexit, hate crimes against people of
certain religions, races, sexualities, and disabilities spiked to all-time
highs. The same has followed Trump’s election. People feel validated by the
words and images of their leaders, even if those words and images don’t lead to
the passing of laws or breaks in the system. I recall one friend’s story of
when Obama was first elected in 2008. As an exchange student in France, she
said that attitudes towards her as an American immediately transformed the
morning Obama’s presidency was announced. Vendors embraced her when she told
them she was an American, a huge change from the days of Bush, when her accent
triggered jokes and snickering.
I
encourage those friends who feel frustrated with their choices to think about
what image they want to create for France. Friends, you have a chance to break
this deadly wave of populism and send a message to the world: we will put an
end to this. As a Bernie supporter, I know personally how disappointing it is
to make a choice between two lesser candidates. But a vote for the lesser of
two evils is just one step in an unending fight for liberty. After Macron is
elected, fight from within. Build up a movement. Hold your representatives
responsible for your interests. Push through better choices for the elections
to come. Or, stay home and whine, if you choose. But France, don’t give up
before Election Day. Otherwise, next Monday morning I will wake up with the
strange feeling that I have already lived through this before.


















